Corner Store NYC Menu: Must-Try Dishes and Hidden Gems
Step into The Corner Store in SoHo, NYC, where the corner store nyc menu brings you the best of new york’s local flavor and good food. You might spot a celebrity—Taylor Swift has stopped by twice. People rave about the wagyu French dip and the lobster frites, both praised in new york media. The pizza rolls get attention for their Instagram-worthy look and taste. The corner store feels like a new york classic, but the restaurant adds a nostalgic twist and keeps things fresh. You get to enjoy great food and soak up the lively new york vibe every time you visit the corner store.
Key Takeaways
The Corner Store offers classic New York comfort food with a fresh, modern twist that makes every dish special.
Must-try dishes include the rich Wagyu French Dip, fancy Lobster & Caviar Roll, and the popular Five Cheese Pizza Rolls.
The bar serves unique martinis made with house-made ingredients and creative techniques, perfect for adventurous drinkers.
Hidden gems like house-made desserts and off-menu surprises add excitement and variety to your dining experience.
Reservations are recommended, especially for early dinner times, and dressing smart elegant helps you fit the cozy, upscale vibe.
Corner Store NYC Menu
You walk into The Corner Store and feel like you’ve stepped into a classic New York spot, but with a twist. The menu brings you back to old-school diners, yet every dish feels new and exciting. The chefs here love to play with nostalgia. They take comfort food you know—like pastrami sandwiches and steak frites—and make it shine with top-notch ingredients and modern cooking. The corner store nyc menu mixes tradition and inventive fare, so you get the best of both worlds. You’ll see why this place is a favorite for locals and visitors who want a diner style meal with a little extra magic.
Wagyu French Dip
If you want to try something unforgettable, order the Wagyu French Dip. This isn’t your average sandwich. The chefs use a 72-hour aged Westholme Australian ribeye, so the beef tastes rich and tender. When your plate arrives, the server pours steaming au jus right at your table. That moment feels special and makes the meal even better. You get a side of horseradish, which adds a sharp kick and balances the flavors. This dish comes from the Butcher’s Counter menu, showing how much care goes into every bite. People talk about this French dip all over new york, and you’ll see why after your first taste.
Tip: Don’t skip the au jus! The tableside pour makes the sandwich juicy and full of flavor.
Lobster & Caviar Roll
You want to feel fancy? Go for the Lobster & Caviar Roll. The corner store nyc menu takes a classic lobster roll and gives it a luxury upgrade. You get sweet, fresh lobster meat tucked into a soft roll, topped with a spoonful of caviar. The salty pop of the caviar mixes perfectly with the buttery lobster. This dish feels like a celebration, and it’s perfect if you want to treat yourself or impress a friend. It’s one of those new york dishes you’ll remember long after your meal.
Caesar Salad
Sometimes you just want a classic done right. The Caesar Salad at the corner store is crisp, cool, and full of flavor. The chefs use crunchy romaine, creamy dressing, and plenty of parmesan. You might find a twist, like house-made croutons or a sprinkle of fresh herbs. This salad works great as a starter or a light main. It’s a simple dish, but here, it feels special—just like everything else on the corner store nyc menu.
Five Cheese Pizza Rolls
You can’t talk about the corner store without mentioning the Five Cheese Pizza Rolls. These are not your average pizza snacks. The kitchen stuffs each roll with a blend of five cheeses, so every bite is gooey and satisfying. The outside gets golden and crisp, making them perfect for sharing. These rolls have become a social media hit, and you’ll see why when you try them. If you love cheesy pepperoni pizza rolls, you’ll want to order these as soon as you sit down. They’re one of the excellent appetizers that keep people coming back.
French Fries with McOli Sauce
French fries are a must at any diner style meal, but here, they get an upgrade. The fries come out hot and crispy, just the way you like them. What makes them stand out is the McOli sauce—a creamy, tangy dip that’s a secret house recipe. You’ll want to dunk every fry and maybe even ask for extra sauce. These fries pair well with steak frites or any main dish. They’re a simple pleasure, but the flavor will surprise you.
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Looking for comfort food? The Spinach & Artichoke Dip is warm, creamy, and packed with flavor. The chefs blend fresh spinach and artichokes with cheese, then bake it until bubbly. You get toasted bread or chips for dipping. This dish feels like a hug in a bowl and is perfect for sharing with friends. It’s another example of how the corner store takes classic new york snacks and makes them shine.
Note: The Spinach & Artichoke Dip is a crowd-pleaser and a great way to start your meal.
The corner store nyc menu brings together the best of new york comfort food and inventive fare. Whether you crave steak frites, a fancy lobster roll, or just some excellent appetizers, you’ll find something to love. Every dish feels familiar but also a little bit special, making your visit to the corner store one to remember.
Hidden Gems
You might think you know everything on the Corner Store NYC menu, but some dishes and drinks hide in plain sight. These hidden gems bring a sense of adventure to your meal. If you love to explore, you’ll want to try these special treats that many people miss.
House-Made Desserts
Save room for dessert. The Corner Store’s pastry team creates sweets that feel both nostalgic and new. You can order the samoa cookie sundae, which takes the classic Girl Scout cookie and turns it into a rich, gooey sundae. Imagine toasted coconut, chocolate, and caramel melting over creamy ice cream. Each spoonful brings back memories, but the flavors taste even better than you remember.
You might also spot rotating pies or cakes, baked fresh every day. Ask your server what’s new. Sometimes, you’ll find a seasonal treat that isn’t on the printed menu. These desserts change often, so you get a surprise each time you visit.
Tip: If you see a dessert you don’t recognize, order it! The pastry chef loves to experiment, and you might discover your new favorite.
International Snacks
The Corner Store doesn’t just stick to American classics. You’ll find snacks inspired by flavors from around the world. Try the dirty martini oysters. These oysters come with a briny, savory topping that tastes just like your favorite cocktail. The kitchen uses house-made brine and fresh herbs to give each oyster a punch of flavor. You get a taste of new york’s love for seafood, but with a twist.
You can also ask about other international snacks. Sometimes, the menu features small plates with global inspiration. These bites pair well with drinks and let you sample something new without committing to a full meal.
Unique Martinis
The bar at The Corner Store takes martinis to a whole new level. You won’t find just the classic version here. The bartenders craft martinis with house-made ingredients and creative techniques. Here are some of the most unique martinis you can try:
Tomato martini: vodka, tomato water, bianco vermouth, and koseret herb. This drink tastes savory and fresh, almost like a garden in a glass.
Sour Cream & Onion martini: cream-washed gin, vermouth, spring onion, and dill. It’s creamy, aromatic, and unlike any martini you’ve had before.
Chamomile-flavored vesper: floral notes make this martini light and unique.
Oli’s Dirty and The Filth: both use house-made brine for a bold, savory flavor. These come as part of a special martini service.
The bartenders make almost every ingredient from scratch, except for the liquor. They use cool techniques like sous vide and fat washing to create new flavors. Each martini comes out icy cold, so you get the best taste with every sip.
Note: If you love oysters, try the dirty martini oysters with one of these martinis. The flavors match perfectly and give you a true new york experience.
Off-Menu Surprises
Sometimes, the best dishes never make it onto the menu. The Corner Store loves to keep things interesting with off-menu surprises. You might hear about a secret snack or a special drink if you chat with your server or bartender. These hidden gems change often, so you never know what you’ll find.
Ask about the chef’s daily creation or a bartender’s favorite cocktail. You could end up with a dish or drink that only a few people in new york have tried. These surprises make every visit feel special and keep you coming back for more.
Pro Tip: Don’t be shy. Ask your server, “What’s not on the menu today?” You might discover a gem that becomes your new go-to order.
Experience & Atmosphere
Nostalgic Vibe
When you walk into The Corner Store, you feel like you’ve stepped into a cozy spot from another era. The main dining area has round booths that frame the room, making it feel calm and inviting. You notice there aren’t too many tables, so the space never feels crowded. This relaxed setting stands out in busy new york. The design team behind the restaurant has over 25 years of experience, and you can see their magic in every detail. They blend classic touches with modern style, creating a place that feels both familiar and fresh. The menu adds to the nostalgia, serving comfort foods that remind you of earlier decades but with a special twist.
You’ll love how the restaurant makes you feel right at home, even if it’s your first visit.
Bar Program
The bar at The Corner Store turns every drink into a show. Bartenders use a silver squid-like tray to serve mini coupettes and a sparkling ice bucket. When you order a martini, you get a tableside presentation with garnishes and carafes. The house martini, called "Oli’s Dirty," uses olive oil-washed vodka for a smooth taste. If you want something bolder, try "The Filth." You can even sample different martinis side by side, making your experience playful and unique. The bar menu features creative drinks like the Sour Cream & Onion Martini, served with dill potato chips. Drinks arrive on trays, carts, or even little trees, adding a touch of theater to your night. The bar program mixes classic and modern new york style, making every visit memorable.
Reservation Tips
Getting a table at The Corner Store can feel tricky, but you have options. The restaurant opens daily at 5 p.m. Recent trends show that early dinner times, like 5 or 5:30 p.m., are the best for reservations. These times give you better availability, a quieter vibe, and faster service. If you want a seat at the bar, try arriving before the doors open. Walk-ins work only if someone cancels, so it’s not a sure thing. Remember to dress "smart elegant" to fit the scene. Plan ahead, and you’ll enjoy a smooth experience at one of new york’s favorite spots.
Reader Picks
Share Your Favorites
You know that feeling when you find a dish you can’t stop thinking about? The Corner Store has a way of turning first-time visitors into regulars. Many guests rave about the Five Cheese Pizza Rolls and the Corner Store Caesar Salad. Some people say the seasonal crudo is a must if you want something fresh and light. Others can’t get enough of the bone-in New York strip, which always comes out juicy and full of flavor.
If you’ve been to The Corner Store, you probably have your own favorites. Maybe you love the house-made desserts or the creative martinis. You might even have a secret off-menu order you want to share. Don’t be shy—drop your picks in the comments! Your tips can help someone else have an amazing meal.
What’s your go-to dish or drink at The Corner Store? Share your story and help other food lovers discover something new!
Tips for First-Timers
Visiting The Corner Store for the first time? You’ll want to make the most of your experience. Here are some tips from diners who know the ropes:
Book your reservation on Resy at least two weeks ahead. Tables fill up fast, and walk-ins are not accepted.
Dress smart elegant. The staff may turn you away if you don’t meet the dress code.
The restaurant feels cozy and upscale, perfect for a special night out.
If you’re under 21, plan to leave by 7 PM.
Arrive on time. You get a 15-minute grace period, but after that, your table might go to someone else.
Parties can have up to four people. If you stay longer than two hours, you may be moved to the bar.
No outside food or drinks allowed.
Flash photography and big cameras are not welcome.
Tell your server about any food allergies before you order.
You’ll notice the drinks cost more than usual, but the house-made ingredients make them worth it. The service is friendly, and you can take your time enjoying each course. If you can’t get a table, try the bar—just be ready for a wait. The Corner Store is a place to relax, celebrate, and make memories. Enjoy every bite!
You’ve seen why the corner store stands out in new york. The restaurant brings you dishes like the Wagyu French Dip and fun surprises like unique martinis. You get a taste of new york classics and hidden gems every time you visit.
Try something new from the menu.
Enjoy the cozy vibe.
Have you found a favorite dish or drink? Share your picks in the comments and help others explore!
FAQ
What time does The Corner Store open?
You can visit The Corner Store starting at 5 p.m. every day. If you want a quieter meal, try coming right when they open. Early times give you the best chance for a table.
Can you walk in without a reservation?
Walk-ins are tough here. Most tables go to people with reservations. If you want to try your luck, arrive before opening and ask about bar seats. Booking ahead is your best bet.
Is there a dress code?
Yes! The Corner Store asks you to dress "smart elegant." That means no gym clothes or flip-flops. You’ll fit right in with a nice shirt, dress, or stylish outfit.
Are kids allowed at The Corner Store?
Kids can join you, but only until 7 p.m. After that, the restaurant becomes adults-only. If you plan to bring younger guests, make an early reservation.
Does the menu change often?
The menu features some classics, but you’ll also find new dishes and desserts each season. Ask your server about specials or off-menu treats. You might discover something new every visit!
See Also
How To Reserve A Table At SoHo’s Corner Store
A Complete Guide To Fort Towson Corner Store Menu
Uncovering Lakeview Corner Store And Pizzeria’s Local Charm
